The Anatomy Of A Broken Insight

When data insights fail, it’s not always because the data is wrong. In fact, broken insights often occur when the data is technically correct but misses the mark in ways that matter. The real issue lies in timing, relevance, or clarity. These insights can be confusing or simply irrelevant when they don’t align with the decision-maker’s current needs. At the same time, insights may arrive too late or get lost in translation, buried under layers of jargon or ineffective visualization.

For example, imagine receiving a report filled with promising data about your marketing campaign. However, the timing is off, and the analysis arrives after the campaign has already ended. Instead of leading to actionable steps, the insight sits unused, and the opportunity is lost. A broken insight fails to drive the necessary change because it’s either irrelevant, too late, or unclear.

The value of insights lies in their ability to represent the truth in data and connect with the decision-maker's goals at the right time, leading to immediate action. Insights should guide decisions, not just report information. In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the core reasons insights break down and how we can fix them.

What is a broken insight?

A broken insight isn’t just an inaccurate data point; it’s a piece of analysis that fails to drive action. Even when the numbers are correct, they may not be effective if they don't resonate with the person who needs to make a decision. Broken insights arise when data fails to connect to the right context, the right timing, or the right audience. These insights are technically sound but fail to be useful because they lack relevance, are delayed, or are too difficult to understand.

Technically correct insights are valuable only when they are presented in a way that speaks directly to the current needs of the business. If the insight doesn’t point to a specific action or doesn’t align with what’s happening at the moment, it’s much less likely to influence decisions effectively. This is why simply presenting raw data is often insufficient; the goal is to turn data into an actionable story that aligns with what the decision-makers care about.

After all, an actionable insight doesn’t just sit in a report waiting to be read; it actively drives decisions that move the business forward.

The three dimensions of insight failure

Insights can fail for a variety of reasons, but three core dimensions consistently contribute to their breakdown: lack of relevance, poor timing, and weak communication. While these might seem like broad issues, they each represent fundamental barriers to effective decision-making. Let’s break them down further.

Relevance: The missing connection

The first dimension of failure is relevance. Even the most accurate insights won’t matter if they don’t align with the current objectives or challenges of the person or team receiving them. For example, consider a financial report that provides an in-depth analysis of last quarter’s performance when the company is already deep into the next quarter’s goals. While the numbers may be spot on, they don't connect to the immediate needs of the decision-makers.

When insights miss the mark, they don’t offer clear value. Instead, they remain informational but irrelevant, leading to disengagement. Decision-makers might glance at the report, realize it’s not aligned with their needs, and move on without action. The lesson here is clear: insights must be tailored to the decision at hand, not just a retrospective view of past performance.

Timing: The race against the clock

Timing is the second dimension that determines whether an insight will be useful. Insights that arrive too late or too early can lose their impact altogether. Take, for instance, a sales team receiving a customer trend report that arrives after the key sales event has passed. Even if the report was well-constructed, its timing renders it useless. On the other hand, insights that come too early can overwhelm teams with information that’s not yet actionable.

For insights to be effective, they need to arrive at the moment when decisions are being made, not after. This means delivering insights in a way that integrates with real-time workflows, rather than relying on static, batch reports that only arrive after the fact. Sigma users know the importance of real-time data; the key here is making sure the timing aligns with when decisions need to be made.

Storytelling: The message that gets lost

Finally, storytelling plays a pivotal role in delivering impactful insights. Even the most relevant, timely insights will fall flat if they’re buried under technical jargon, too many data points, or confusing visuals. Clear communication is the bridge between raw data and actionable insights. Without it, the message is lost.

Consider a marketing dashboard that is packed with numbers but doesn’t clearly indicate why the numbers matter. Or perhaps a financial report that focuses on raw performance metrics without connecting those numbers to business outcomes. Insights are only valuable when they tell a story that is easy to follow and directly ties into actionable steps. In other words, the narrative is just as important as the data itself. If stakeholders can’t easily grasp the meaning of the insight, the likelihood of it driving action diminishes significantly.

How silos and handoffs contribute to broken insights

One of the most significant barriers to effective data insights is the organizational structure. Silos and inefficient handoffs between teams often prevent data from being used at the right time and in the right way. Even with the best analytical tools, if teams don’t communicate well or share a common understanding of business goals, insights can fail to drive meaningful action.

Analysts and data teams often lack sufficient insight into the business context and decision-making timeline. Without this understanding, they may generate reports and dashboards that are filled with useful data but ultimately miss the mark. For example, an analyst may produce a detailed analysis of customer satisfaction metrics, but if they aren’t aware that the company is focused on accelerating product development for the next quarter, the analysis won’t provide any actionable value. The right insight needs to connect directly with the team’s immediate goals and priorities, not just present data for data’s sake.

On the flip side, stakeholders may not always know what they need or be able to articulate the right questions to the data teams. This lack of clarity can create a situation where the insights delivered don’t align with the business needs. Decision-makers might request a broad set of data, not knowing that what they really need is a targeted analysis on a specific metric. When there’s no clear communication between the analysts and business leaders, it leads to misaligned expectations, resulting in data that’s not actionable or timely.

In many organizations, data doesn’t reside in a single platform. Instead, it’s scattered across different systems, owned by different teams, each with its own goals. When insights are derived from disparate sources, it becomes difficult to create a cohesive narrative. For example, a sales team may rely on a CRM tool to track leads, while the marketing team uses a separate platform for campaign tracking. If these systems aren’t integrated, it’s challenging for insights to paint a complete picture, leaving critical gaps that decision-makers can’t act upon effectively.

This fragmented approach also means that ownership of the data can be unclear. When different teams are responsible for separate data sets, it can lead to delays, bottlenecks, and handoffs that interrupt the flow of insights. Each handoff introduces the potential for misinterpretation or missed context, especially when information is passed between systems or departments that aren’t aligned on the same metrics or goals.

The myth of “If we build it, they’ll use it”

One of the most common misconceptions in the world of business intelligence is the belief that simply creating dashboards and reports will lead to meaningful insights and action. This idea suggests that as long as a dashboard exists, users will naturally engage with it and make decisions based on the data. But the reality is much more complicated. Building tools alone is not enough. The problem lies in the assumption that data consumers will use dashboards just because they are available or “built into” the workflow.

Dashboards without purpose

In many organizations, dashboards are built to provide data on a broad range of metrics, but they fail to answer the specific questions stakeholders need answered. While dashboards can display lots of information, the lack of a focused purpose often leads to underuse. Users may be overwhelmed with the sheer volume of data, unsure of what to prioritize, or even unsure if the data presented aligns with their actual needs. For example, consider a sales dashboard that presents data on performance across many different regions, but doesn't prioritize key performance indicators (KPIs) that directly align with the sales team's immediate goals, such as closing rates or lead conversions. As a result, the dashboard might not be used as frequently because it doesn’t drive the most relevant decisions.

Users are overwhelmed with data

Data overload is another critical issue in the traditional dashboard model. When teams are bombarded with a high volume of data that isn’t organized or tailored to their immediate needs, they can quickly lose interest. Instead of providing clarity, these dashboards become a source of frustration, causing decision-makers to abandon them entirely. This is especially true when they are presented with static reports that don’t evolve or adapt to the changing needs of the business.

To overcome this challenge, the focus should shift from just building dashboards to building insightful, tailored dashboards that deliver value. This requires understanding the specific needs of each department and crafting dashboards that surface the most relevant information at the right time, with actionable recommendations. If the insights don’t fit seamlessly into the workflow, they are likely to be overlooked or ignored.

Insights delivered in context, not in a dashboard

Insights must be delivered in context, not simply displayed in a dashboard for the sake of visibility. Consider how people naturally make decisions. They don’t sift through endless rows of data to find what they need; instead, they are presented with relevant, timely insights that directly connect to current goals or objectives. 

For example, imagine a marketing manager who receives an email alert about an underperforming campaign, with clear actionable recommendations such as reallocation of budget, new ad creative suggestions, or timing adjustments. This contextual delivery of insights ensures that users not only see the data but understand what it means for their current strategy, prompting immediate action.

Dashboards can still play a role, but they should be part of a larger system where insights are delivered in real-time, in a digestible format, and with clear next steps. When insights are embedded directly into workflows (whether that’s through email, Slack, or even in-app notifications), they are more likely to be acted upon.

What good insights actually look like

When we talk about good insights, we’re referring to those pieces of analysis that drive real decisions. These insights deliver data and provide clarity, focusing on the right details and guiding teams toward specific actions. A good insight doesn’t just sit in a report; it sparks movement and accelerates decision-making. So, what makes an insight truly actionable?

Timely and aligned with current decisions

The most impactful insights are those that are timely and aligned with current business goals. An insight that arrives in the middle of a quarterly strategy meeting has the potential to shift the course of the discussion. In contrast, one that arrives a week later is irrelevant as the decision has already been made.

A key point here is the connection between the insight and the ongoing work. For example, imagine a product team working on a new feature and receiving an insight about customer feedback that suggests a change to the feature. This insight, delivered in the middle of the development cycle, could influence the next iteration and help avoid costly mistakes. Timing is everything, as relevant insights need to be delivered at the point where they can truly make a difference.

Anchored to a relatable metric or business impact

Good insights also anchor themselves to business outcomes. When an insight is tied to a specific metric or clearly linked to a business objective, it becomes much easier to see its value. Take a marketing campaign, for instance. An insight that reports an increase in conversion rates directly tied to changes in ad spend offers a clear path to action.

For stakeholders, knowing how the insight impacts the broader business goals is critical. If a marketing report simply shows performance across channels without connecting the data to actual sales growth or customer retention, it’s less likely to inspire action. A well-anchored insight, on the other hand, connects the dots between the data and a tangible business result.

Delivered in the right format

Insights need to be presented in a format that is easily digestible and relevant to the recipient’s needs. Whether that’s an email alert, a Slack message, or an embedded notification in a project management tool, the format of delivery can significantly affect how quickly the insight is acted upon.

For example, sending a detailed PowerPoint presentation to a sales manager who is on the move might not be as effective as sending a quick, actionable insight through a tool like Slack, highlighting a specific trend in real-time. It’s not just about delivering the information but about delivering it in a way that integrates into the decision-maker’s workflow.

Many teams find that short-form insights, such as an email or chat notification with actionable steps, are far more effective than lengthy reports. The key is to focus on clarity and actionability, ensuring the format aligns with the user’s needs at that specific moment.

Includes a recommended next step

The most powerful insights always come with a recommendation that tells the recipient what to do with the data. When an insight simply presents numbers without any guidance, it can leave decision-makers wondering, "Now what?" This lack of direction causes hesitation and slows down action.

For instance, a finance team might receive a report showing an uptick in operational costs. While the data is important, it’s the next step that matters: Should they cut back on certain expenses? Should they investigate the cause of the increase? A good insight doesn’t just report the data; it provides the context and recommendations necessary to act on it. In this way, insights act as a catalyst for change.

Building workflows that turn insights into action

To ensure that insights don’t just sit idle in a dashboard or report, organizations need to create workflows that seamlessly transform them into tangible actions. Turning insights into action demands a structured process that facilitates the connection between data and decision-making.

Create shared definitions and KPIs to anchor insights

Consistency is key when it comes to interpreting data. Insights are far more effective when the entire organization is aligned on the same key performance indicators (KPIs) and metrics. Shared definitions of what each metric means and how it connects to business outcomes help ensure that everyone is on the same page when it comes to decision-making.

For example, if different departments define customer retention rate differently, insights around this metric may confuse and lead to inconsistent actions. To avoid this, it’s important to establish common definitions early on and ensure that every team is working with the same understanding of the data. This alignment helps streamline the decision-making process and ensures that the insights being shared have a clear, consistent meaning across the organization.

Build delivery triggers based on key business events

Another important element of building workflows that turn insights into action is the use of delivery triggers. These are events or conditions that automatically trigger the delivery of insights when certain criteria are met. For instance, a sales team might receive an automated notification when a key sales target has been met, prompting them to adjust marketing strategies or increase inventory.

Setting up these triggers ensures that insights are delivered at the moment of relevance, reducing the risk of information being ignored or overlooked. This kind of real-time data delivery directly supports decision-making by presenting insights when they’re most needed, allowing teams to take immediate action without having to dig through reports or wait for scheduled meetings.

Solve the root causes of broken insights

At the heart of broken insights lies a communication and workflow problem, not just a technical one. Insights often fail to connect with the decision-making process at the right time, in the right context, or in a clear way. Fixing these broken insights doesn’t require better data; it requires a shift in how organizations deliver and use the data they already have.

The root causes of irrelevance, poor timing, and unclear communication can all be resolved through thoughtful strategies that focus on improving workflow design, enhancing team collaboration, and refining data delivery methods. By improving how insights are shared, ensuring they align with business goals, and delivering them at the right moment, organizations can turn their data into actionable intelligence.

Ultimately, organizations that fix the root causes of broken insights can make decisions faster and with more confidence. By focusing on the timely, relevant, and clear delivery of insights, businesses can shift from simply collecting data to using that data to drive tangible outcomes. 

When insights are well-timed, actionable, and delivered in relevant formats, they stop being a static element of your reports or dashboards. They become an ongoing part of your workflow, fueling decisions and driving real progress. Solving the root causes of broken insights is how businesses start moving more confidently toward their goals, making data not just a byproduct of their operations, but a strategic asset in driving business growth.

‍